Trending
July 8, 2024

SOCIAL PROGRAMS

Our Social Programs are in trouble and figuring out what we do about it is a tough issue

The problem is one of cost – the cost of Social Security and Medicare is rising and will increase this decade and continue rising at least through 2050.

We spent $5,124 per US person on Social Security and Medicare in 2019 – that number will increase by about $2,200 (in 2019 dollars) – to about $7,300 – per US person in 2030.

Medicaid cost pressures are no different.

There are three factors that, in combination, cause the problem:

Pay-as-you-go Social Programs

US social programs masquerade as ‘funded’ plans: they are not

Benefits are paid from current taxes

There are no national savings for our collective old age

Americans are getting old

The US is aging: the proportion of the population who are seniors (70+) increases 60% – 2030 vs. 2010

7 working age (20-69) to 1 retired age (70+) person in 2010; 4 in 2030

US healthcare cost growth

Healthcare costs (so Medicare costs) grow faster than the economy

Per Medicare enrollee cost expected to increase by 27% (constant dollars) in the next 10 years through 2030

Are there solutions?

Yes: there are always solutions, but most of them are difficult and finding a way forward requires tough crunchy choices and leadership.

Here are some:

  • Pare back the benefit promise (e.g. increase retirement age)
  • Raise taxes
  • Encourage immigration, especially of well educated people
  • Reform the healthcare markets so that American people are paying a sensible price for this service
  • Cut other government expenditures: the only category large enough to make a material difference is defense (but, Crunchicrant argues, we are not even close to figuring out the threats/risk we now face as a nation, nor how we should defend against them).

Or a mixture of all 5

In sufficient dosage, all of these remedies work: most of them require time – perhaps a generation – to action. What is the plan?

Social programs – how to fix them